Debbie Gupta, the Director of Life Insurance and Financial Advice Supervision at the FCA wrote a “Dear CEO” letter to every defined benefit pension transfer adviser this week. The letter outlined the FCA’s concerns of the “increasing number of cases where the actions of firms are resulting in significant harm to consumers’ financial well-being“.
The FCA also outlined in the letter their Assessing Suitability Review 2 plan, which will focus on the advice consumers receive from firm who offer defined benefit pension transfer advice. The FCA rightly believe that many consumers are receiving bad advice from some advisers. The FCA intend to investigate and penalise the firms that provide bad pension transfer advise.
Key areas of concern
Since the introduction of Pension Freedom consumers have been given greater freedom on what they can do with their pension pots such as cashing in their pension at 55. These new freedoms have led to a rush of consumers taking advantage of the new pension freedom rules, with many receiving bad advice or falling victims of pension scams. In some cases consumers have lost their entire pension funds.
The FCA list four main key areas concerns as:
- Receiving unsuitable advice for their needs and objectives
- Falling victim to pension and investment scams
- Not receiving redress as a result of the non-payment of Financial Ombudsman Service awards and/or failing firms being unable to compensate consumers
- Paying excessive fees or charges for products and services
The FCA will increase their focus on these areas as part of their wider supervision of firms over the next two years.
Why are the FCA so concerned about defined benefit pension transfer advise?
Defined benefit pension transfer advise has been on the forefront of the FCA’s action plan for many years now and will continue to do so for some time. This is because Defined Benefit Pensions offer very good risk free benefits in retirement. In the majority of cases a consumer would be better off leaving their defined benefit pension where it is rather than transferring it out of the scheme. Many consumers are receiving bad advise and transferring their pensions out of DB Pension schemes and leaving them worse off in retirement.
However in certain circumstances a consumer could be better off transferring out of the scheme. As a defined benefit pension transfer specialist we are under a legal obligation to provide the consumer and the FCA with a full suitability report and analysis on whether transferring a Defined Benefit Pension out of a scheme would be appropriate for the consumer. If our findings reveal the consumer will be worse off then we would advise them not to transfer the pension, even if it is not the outcome they were hoping for.
As part of our defined benefit pension transfer analysis, we carry out a full fact find on the pensions, their values, their retirement benefits and the clients current financial situation. It is only once we have all this information we will provide our recommendations. In addition to this our staff and pension specialist are not financially rewarded by the number of transfers they complete, they are measured by the quality of advice they give, whether that is to take money out of your pension or not.
Why transfer a defined benefit pension?
There are many reason why a consumer might consider transferring their defined benefit pension scheme, such as starting a business, clearing debt or paying off their mortgage. Everyone’s circumstances are slightly different so a personal, bespoke approach is required in order to make an appropriate and suitable recommendation.
In some circumstances your employer may be closing the scheme and offered you a enhanced transfer value and incentives to transfer out. Many employers are closing their DB Pension Schemes because they are struggling to meet the ongoing cost as their retired employees live longer.
It is clear that many consumers can benefit from transferring defined benefit pensions, however it is vital that they receive specialist and appropriate advise on the risks and benefits of doing so.
Grove Pension Solutions welcomes the FCA’s latest announcement and believe it will help consumers get the best possible advice and stop unprofessional advisers from harming the consumers future retirement plans.
FCA “Dear CEO” letter in full:
Portfolio strategy letter for financial advisers
As set out in our Approach to Supervision, we assign firms to a portfolio based on their primary business model. We regularly analyse each portfolio and agree a strategy to take pre-emptive action on the firms and issues posing the greatest harm.
Your firm is part of the portfolio of firms categorised as financial advisers. I am writing to all firms in the portfolio to set out our approach to tackling key areas of concern with financial advice firms
and summarise the action we expect you to undertake.
Why financial advisers are a key FCA priority
Consumers are being asked to take more responsibility for an increasing number of complex financial decisions. Financial advisers have a valuable role to play in helping consumers navigate these choices and deliver the right solutions for their needs and objectives. However, we are seeing an increasing number of cases where the actions of firms are resulting in significant harm to consumers’ financial well-being. Preventing harm in this portfolio is therefore a key priority. We have identified four key ways in which consumers of financial advice may be harmed:
- receiving unsuitable advice for their needs and objectives
- falling victim to pension and investment scams
- not receiving redress as a result of the non-payment of Financial Ombudsman Service awards and/or failing firms being unable to compensate consumers
- paying excessive fees or charges for products and services
There will be increased focus on these areas as part of our wider supervision of firms over the next two years.
Assessing suitability of advice and disclosure
Following on from our Assessing Suitability Review in 2017, we will be carrying out further work on the suitability of advice and associated disclosure (known as ‘Assessing Suitability Review 2’). The review will focus on initial and ongoing advice to consumers on taking an income in retirement. This evolving market has changed significantly following the pension freedom reforms and we want to assess the outcomes consumers are receiving.
Action to take
You need to ensure the advice you provide is suitable, costs and charges are disclosed clearly, and you act in the best interests of your clients. Conflicts of interest must be identified and where they cannot be prevented, disclosed and managed.
Defined benefit pension transfer advice
We have repeatedly made clear our expectations of financial advisers, as well as strengthening the rules around defined benefit (DB) pension transfer advice. Despite this, too much advice is still not of an acceptable standard. We also remain concerned firms are recommending large numbers of consumers transfer out of their DB pension schemes despite our stance that transfers are likely to be unsuitable for most clients. As a result, we will continue to focus on this area until the quality of pension transfer advice reaches the same standard as the wider advice market.
We are undertaking a wide-ranging programme of data-led supervision work assessing firms’ DB advice processes and client outcomes. In July 2019 we issued a consultation paper on various proposals regarding DB pension transfer advice, including proposed changes to the charging models firms use. We plan to publish finalised Handbook rules and guidance in Q1 2020. If you give DB pension transfer advice you should consider how our proposals might affect your future business.
Action to take
We expect you to start from the assumption that a pension transfer is not likely to be suitable for your client. You need to ensure you have identified and are managing the risks associated with DB transfer business. This includes any conflict of interest caused by your charging structures, both for advice on the decision to transfer and any ongoing investment advice.
Inadequate fact finding creates a high risk that your advice will be unsuitable. You must ensure you gather all the necessary information to carry out appropriate pension transfer analysis and make a suitable recommendation. You also need to ensure you have adequate advisory, transfer specialist and compliance resources for your business.
Pensions and investment scams
Significant numbers of consumers are still being targeted by scammers. Scammers are also becoming increasingly sophisticated in developing investments designed to defeat firms’ due diligence. Key areas of risk include:
- authorised firms receiving introductions from introducers or lead generators, particularly, where the introducer has inappropriate influence on how the authorised firm carries out its business (such as where the introducer influences the final investment choice)
- authorised firms delegating regulated activities, particularly where they outsource their advice process to unauthorised entities or other authorised firms that do not have the relevant permissions, or are not their appointed representatives
- principal firms having inadequate oversight of their appointed representatives
- authorised firms failing to undertake adequate due diligence on products and services they recommend (for example, non-standard, illiquid investments)
- investments containing non-standard assets, complex structures and/or high charges
We will continue to focus our intelligence and supervisory activities on taking prompt and assertive action on the firms and individuals who facilitate or participate in scams.
Action to take
Firms and individual advisers play an important role in helping prevent scams. You need to be aware of the current risks and ensure your advice processes and systems are robust enough to avoid them.
If you think a firm or an individual is involved in wrongdoing, you should report it to our firm queries team on +44 (0)300 500 0597 or email@example.com. The information you provide will be treated in confidence.
If you would like to report anonymously, you can speak to our whistleblowing team:
call: +44 (0)20 7066 9200 during office hours or leave a message
write to: Intelligence Department (Ref PIDA), Financial Conduct Authority, 12 Endeavour Square, London E20 1JN
Adequate financial resources and professional indemnity insurance
We are concerned some financial advisers are holding inadequate financial resources and/or professional indemnity insurance (PII) for the business activities they carry out. This has been an issue with a number of the firms assessed as part of our work on DB pension transfer advice. Where this is the case, it increases the risk of firms being unable to put things right where they have caused harm to their clients. The inability to compensate consumers, and the transfer of these costs to other market participants via the FSCS levy, is unfair and places an unnecessary burden on other firms. It also threatens confidence and participation in financial services markets.
We have seen cases where firms have exclusions for particular business lines (such as providing advice on DB transfers), or have sub-limits on particular business lines below the minimum requirements (eg less than the €1.85m for ‘IDD’ firms). Some firms have excesses on claims which are at such a level as to render the cover materially ineffective. In those circumstances, we take the view the exclusion/excess or sub-limits unreasonably limit cover and do not comply with our rules.
We will be focusing on whether financial advisers have adequate financial resources and PII as part of our ongoing supervisory work. This will include the steps firms’ senior management have taken to maintain valid PII.
Action to take
Financial adviser firms (that are Personal Investment Firms) must meet the financial resources requirements set out in Chapter 13 of our Interim Prudential sourcebook: Investment Business (and other relevant parts of our Handbook). This includes a requirement to maintain compliant PII.
You need to maintain valid PII for past and current business so that there is no break in cover. Your PII policy must not be subject to conditions or exclusions which unreasonably limit its cover. In such circumstances, you should stop providing advice on those business lines until you can secure appropriate cover or risk being in breach of our rules.
If your firm has permissible exclusions you will need to hold additional capital in line with our rules. If your firm does not have PII cover at all for certain types of business, you should not be advising on that business. Where relevant, you should also apply for the relevant permission to be removed (for example, advising on pension transfers and pension opt-outs).
Ban on promotion of speculative mini-bonds to retail consumers
We recently used our product intervention powers to ban the mass marketing of speculative mini-bonds to retail customers. The restriction came into force 1 January 2020 and will last for 12 months while we consult on whether to make permanent rules. We also published guidance on our existing rules for firms approving the financial promotions of unauthorised persons.
Action to take
You should consider whether the steps you have taken in approving financial promotions in the past were sufficient to ensure they satisfied our requirements. If you become aware a financial promotion you have approved previously does not comply with our rules, you should withdraw your approval. If you approve the financial promotions of unauthorised persons, have done so in the past 12 months, or intend to begin doing so, we request that you inform us by emailing Section21Approval@fca.org.uk.
Further information on the range of investments covered by the ban and our guidance is available on our website.
Senior Managers and Certification Regime
The Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) was extended to most FCA-authorised solo-regulated firms, including financial advisers, on 9 December 2019. The regime sets a new standard of personal conduct for everyone working in financial services. It aims to reduce harm to consumers, strengthen market integrity and encourage the positive transformation of the industry’s culture.
We will be assessing compliance with the new SM&CR requirements as part of our ongoing supervisory work.
Action to take
We expect you to ensure your firm’s Senior Managers have a clear understanding of their roles and responsibilities and that staff, including Senior Managers and certified staff, have the appropriate skills and capabilities needed to deliver good customer outcomes.
From 9 December, the Approved Persons Regime (APR) no longer applies to FSMA authorised firms. However, the provisions of the APR and the relevant APR-controlled functions continue to apply to appointed representatives. This is because the legislation does not give us power to apply the SM&CR to them. If you are a Principal firm, you remain fully responsible for ensuring your appointed representatives and networks comply with our rules, including the APR. You should already have structures and processes in place to do this.
The UK government has committed to the UK leaving the EU on 31 January 2020. When that happens, the UK will enter an implementation period during which it will negotiate its future relationship with the EU. The implementation period is due to operate until 31 December 2020. During this time EU law would continue to apply in the UK. We expect you to consider how the end of the implementation period will affect you and your customers, and what action you may need to take to be ready for 1 January 2021. For information on Brexit, including what the implementation period will mean, visit our website. We will update our pages after exit.
What you need to do next
We expect you to consider and discuss this letter with your fellow directors and/or Board and agree what, if any, further action(s) you should take. We also expect Principal firms to share the contents of the letter with their appointed representatives.
If you have any questions about anything in this letter please contact your normal supervisory contact on 0300 500 0597. This is the primary point of contact for your firm’s day-to-day interactions with us, and further details of how we can be reached are available on our website.
However, we recognise that there may be occasions when your firm faces urgent issues of strategic importance. In such circumstances, please contact Chris McGrath on 020 7066 7818 or at Chris.Mcgrath2@fca.org.uk.
Director of Life Insurance & Financial Advice Supervision